Miss Nicola,
Thank you so much for putting in the time, effort, and expertise on this!
Here are my thoughts - don't shoot me!
I love *parts* of both designs!
The 'mechanical' banner and photo size are really appealing for the same reasons you state - they look dead-on professional! But I don't care for how the design crop in the badge and avatar sizes - this is where it gets a little 'corporate' feeling.
These are also the two sizes I'm more likely to use in different places, so that is why I'm focused there.
The organic set is exactly reversed for me, LOL LOOOOVEEE the avatar and badge sizes! But in the larger pieces the multiple darker stamped hands create a muddy feel, not a warm feel, and from a design standpoint, the negative space between the hearts and the multiples is too much - it isn't cohesive like the mechanical set.
Maybe that is why you prefer the 'mechanical set?
Just a thought, Thanks again!!!!!
Perri